All articles
Tax Strategy9 min read

Switched Jobs Mid-Year and Over-Contributed to Your 401(k)? Here's the Fix

Steady Wealth · November 22, 2026

Threads like "401k reached cap before changing jobs" and "accidentally over contributed to 401k" show up on Blind every year, usually from someone who did everything right at each individual job and still ended up over the IRS limit. The TurboTax community forums have the same pattern under titles like "over contribution to 401k" and "excess deferral contribution," almost always posted in February or March, right when W-2s arrive and the math finally lines up.

The cause is structural, not a mistake either employer made. Here's why it happens, how to spot it on your own W-2s, and what to do before the fix window closes.

Why no employer catches this

The IRS elective deferral limit under Internal Revenue Code section 402(g) is a per-person limit. It applies to you, across every 401(k), 403(b), and most 457 plans you contribute to in a calendar year, not separately to each plan. Federal regulation 26 CFR 1.401(a)-30 requires a qualified plan to cap elective deferrals "on behalf of an individual under the plan and all other plans, contracts, or arrangements of the employer maintaining the plan," and IRS guidance states plainly that you have an excess deferral if the total of your elective deferrals to all plans is more than the deferral limit for the year.

The problem is that each employer's payroll and plan administrator can only see contributions made to its own plan. Employer A has no record of what you contributed at Employer B, and Employer B has no record of what you contributed at Employer A, because unrelated employers don't share payroll data with each other. Each plan independently caps your contributions at the annual limit, and each one will happily let you contribute right up to that limit, with no idea that you already did the same thing somewhere else this year.

So someone maxes out a 401(k) at one job, switches employers mid-year, and starts contributing again at the new job on day one, often through a default payroll deduction percentage set during onboarding. Neither employer's system flags anything, because neither one is wrong about its own plan. The overage only exists when you add both W-2s together, which is something neither employer's payroll software does for you.

How to check your own W-2s

Box 12 of your W-2 reports your elective deferrals with specific codes: code D for traditional pre-tax 401(k) contributions, and code AA for designated Roth 401(k) contributions. According to the IRS's General Instructions for Forms W-2 and W-3, elective deferrals (codes D, E, F, S) and designated Roth contributions (AA, BB, EE) under all plans you participated in during the year are limited to the same combined annual figure.

If you had 2 or more employers with a 401(k) in the same calendar year, add up the Box 12 code D and code AA amounts across every W-2 you received for that year. If the combined total is higher than that year's limit, you have an excess deferral, even though no single W-2 shows a number over the limit on its own.

The 2026 limit

For 2026, the IRS set the elective deferral limit at $24,500, up from $23,500 in 2025, according to IRS Notice 2025-67 and the IRS's November 2026 contribution limit announcement. Workers who turn 50 or older at any point in 2026 can contribute an additional $8,000 in catch-up contributions, for a combined limit of $32,500. Workers who turn 60 through 63 during the year get a larger catch-up of $11,250 instead, under the SECURE 2.0 provision that applies to that specific age band, for a combined limit of $35,750.

These are the numbers to add your combined Box 12 amounts against, not the limit from whichever year you happen to remember.

A worked example

Maria earns $140,000 at Employer A and sets her 401(k) deferral percentage aggressively in January, planning to max out for the year. By the end of June, she's contributed the full $24,500 2026 limit through Employer A's plan and her payroll deductions stop automatically, since the plan itself won't let her exceed the limit.

In July, Maria takes a new job at Employer B, with a $150,000 salary. Employer B's onboarding defaults every new hire into the 401(k) at a 6% deferral rate starting with the first paycheck. Maria doesn't think to change it, since she assumes the system will handle contribution limits the way her last job's did. Over the 6 months from July through December, 6% of her new salary works out to roughly $9,000 in additional contributions, and Employer B's plan has no reason to stop her, because she hasn't hit its own internal limit tracking for its own plan.

Her combined 2026 elective deferrals: $24,500 at Employer A plus $9,000 at Employer B equals $33,500, which is $9,000 over the $24,500 limit. Neither employer's payroll system ever saw a number that looked wrong.

If Maria does nothing, that $9,000 excess has a double taxation problem. She already paid no tax on it going in, because it was deducted pre-tax from her paycheck, which means it's added to her taxable income for 2026 as an excess deferral regardless of what she does next. If she doesn't request a corrective distribution, that same $9,000 stays in her 401(k) and grows, and when she eventually withdraws it in retirement, it gets taxed again as ordinary income, this time along with whatever it earned along the way. The same dollars are taxed twice.

If Maria requests a timely return of excess deferrals, the $9,000 (plus any earnings it generated while sitting in the plan) gets distributed back to her in cash, and she owes tax on it once, for 2026, the year she actually deferred it. No 10% early withdrawal penalty applies to a timely corrective distribution, and the double taxation problem never materializes.

How to fix it, and the deadline that matters

The fix is called a return of excess deferrals, and it has a hard deadline. Treasury Regulation 1.402(g)-1(e)(2)(i) requires that a corrective distribution of excess deferrals, along with any earnings, be made by April 15 of the year following the year the excess occurred. For a 2026 excess, that's April 15, 2027.

To start the process:

  1. Add up your Box 12 codes D and AA across all W-2s for the year to confirm the excess and the exact dollar amount.
  2. Contact the plan administrator at one of the employers (you choose which one, it doesn't have to be the employer where the excess technically happened) and tell them you have an excess deferral under section 402(g) that needs to be corrected before April 15.
  3. Complete whatever corrective distribution paperwork that plan requires. Most plan administrators have a standard form for this exact situation, since it isn't rare.
  4. Report the excess as income for the year it was deferred, following the 1099-R the plan sends you for the corrective distribution. Earnings distributed along with the excess get reported separately, for the year you actually receive them.

Since unrelated employers don't share this information, the plan you contact has no automatic way of knowing about the excess either. You're the one who has to notice it and request the correction, and the April 15 date is not something a plan administrator will remind you about on their own.

What happens if you miss April 15

If the excess deferral isn't distributed by April 15 of the following year, a corrective distribution generally isn't available anymore outside of a normal plan distribution event, such as separating from that employer later or reaching retirement age. At that point the double taxation outcome described above becomes close to unavoidable: the excess was already taxed as income in the year it was deferred, and it will be taxed again as ordinary income whenever it eventually comes out of the plan.

Filing a tax extension for your federal return does not push back this specific deadline. The April 15 date for requesting a return of excess deferrals is fixed regardless of whether you extend your filing deadline for the rest of your return.

Avoiding this the next time you switch jobs

If you're maxing out a 401(k) and expect to change jobs during the year, the simplest fix is tracking your running total yourself rather than trusting either employer's plan to catch it, since neither one can see the other's numbers. Before setting a contribution percentage at a new job, check your most recent pay stub from the old job for your year-to-date elective deferral total, and set the new plan's contribution rate (or a flat dollar override, if the plan allows one) so the combined total lands at the limit instead of past it.

If you're deciding how aggressively to front-load contributions at a single employer in the first place, the tradeoffs around maxing out early versus spreading contributions evenly cover the employer match side of that same calculation, which matters even more once a job change is added to the mix. And if the job change involved more than just a 401(k), such as an outstanding loan balance from the old plan, the separate deadline that applies to 401(k) loans after a layoff or job change is worth checking at the same time, since it runs on its own clock. Either way, understanding how your employer's match actually gets calculated helps explain why a mid-year contribution change, in either direction, can affect more than just the deferral limit.

This is exactly the kind of detail that's easy to lose track of across 2 separate payroll systems and 2 sets of year-to-date numbers you only see one at a time. If you're logging account balances in Steady Wealth already, adding a note with your running 401(k) contribution total each time you update is a quick way to catch a combined overage before tax season does it for you, instead of after.

Frequently asked questions

Which employer's plan should I ask to return the excess deferral?

Either one. The excess deferral rule doesn't require the correction to come from a specific plan, so you can request the return from whichever employer's plan administrator is easier to reach or has a faster process. Many people choose the plan at their current employer, since that relationship is more active, but the plan at a former employer is required to process the request too if you ask before April 15.

What if I don't realize I over-contributed until after April 15?

A corrective distribution of the excess generally isn't available anymore outside of a normal distribution event from the plan, such as leaving that employer or reaching retirement age. The excess amount was already taxed as income for the year you deferred it, and it will be taxed again as ordinary income when it's eventually distributed from the plan, so the double taxation described above becomes difficult to avoid once the deadline passes.

Do I lose the employer match on the excess amount too?

The employer match itself isn't withdrawn as part of a return of excess deferrals, since the 402(g) limit applies to your own elective deferrals, not to employer contributions. Employer contributions fall under a separate, much higher limit (the section 415(c) annual additions limit). The match you received on the excess dollars generally stays in the plan, though plan terms can vary, so confirm the specific treatment with your plan administrator when you request the correction.

Does this apply if some of my contributions were Roth 401(k) instead of traditional?

Yes. The section 402(g) limit covers the combined total of traditional (Box 12 code D) and Roth (Box 12 code AA) elective deferrals across all plans, not two separate limits. If you split contributions between a traditional 401(k) at one job and a Roth 401(k) at another, you still need to add both together against the same annual limit.

Will either employer get in trouble for this?

No. Because the limit is tracked per individual across unrelated employers, and no employer can see what you contributed elsewhere, neither plan did anything wrong by letting you contribute up to its own internal limit. This is also why the correction responsibility falls on you rather than on either employer's HR or payroll team.

Free email course

The Tax-Smart Wealth Builder

$2.1 trillion sits in 31.9 million forgotten 401(k) accounts. 5 emails on account priority, Roth vs Traditional, and keeping more of what you earn.

5 emails, 1 email a day. See what each one covers

Start the free course

Free, 1 email a day. Unsubscribe with 1 click.

Keep reading